"Uncle Derek Says"

Neoregelia carcharodon now 'Blue Shark'

Derek Butcher "1996 was a vintage year because it was when Len Colgan and myself went to Orlando to the World Bromeliad Conference. I was especially after a true Neoregelia fosteriana and a true N. carcharodon and Harry had written that both were in Florida, admittedly side by side with wrongly named ones - it depended where you looked! At Pineapple Place I saw both species but when nobody was looking I poked around the inflorescence of N. fosteriana and convinced myself it was not compound and was thus incorrectly named. The N. carcharodon was the 'Rubra' that Harry said was true and it looked so good I just had to have one. I bought a N. carcharodon and which was an offset (not a seedling) and it survived quarantine but took lots of years to acclimatise. It would not flower but each offset did look like it was getting used to Adelaide. In 2006 an offset went to Peter Tristram in NSW and in 2007 another offset went to Mick Romanowski in Melbourne.

I was somehat surprised when in Jan 2008 Peter Tristram sent me photos of the plant in flower and with blue petals. Panic! Petals are supposed to be white!

Off to Harry Luther for advice. Plant not N. carcharodon but he did say N. carcharodon was on the BSI seed list in the 1990's. As Bill Morris instilled in me years ago, "Seed-raisers must always analyse their results!" Alas few do so!

This plant with the blue flowers needs a cultivar name and what better than 'Blue Shark'. The 'blue' to cover the error as well as the colour of the petals and 'Shark' to link it to 'carcharodon'.

Even though I got my offset so long ago, there is a great chance that plants called Neoregelia carcharodon are still lurking in Florida 'waters' waiting to catch the unwary. It is possible that it could also have been imported to Queensland. So when next your N. carcharodon flowers please check the petal colour which should be white.

Note added August 2008.
The current view is that the 'carcharodon rubra' of the 1990's is in fact Neoregelia gigas described in 2007. If you are looking for Neoregelia carcharodon it is very close, if not identical, to N. 'Silver' . This is where I see we have advantages over the binomial system with clonal cultivar names which don't change. All you do is move the Cultivar name to the species which is flavour of the month! (a term used by Cinema goers in the 1950's). Rarely, if ever do you see taxonomists refer to a particular named clone that is known to be in cultivation before it is named under the ICBN rules."

Neoregelia 'Blue Shark'
Neoregelia 'Blue Shark
Neoregelia 'Blue Shark'
Neoregelia 'Blue Shark

Click on the thumbnails to view the pictures.
Send your comments and opinions to UncleDerekSays@fcbs.org
Your comments will be added to this page.

Back To
Uncle Derek Says Index

Photo Credits: Peter Tristram


http://fcbs.org/